Please Tell Us Your City

Knowing your city will help us provide relevant content to you.

Sorry! No matching results found. Try again.Error Identifying Your Location.

Log in to CarWale

Please enter your password
Forgot password?
Please enter your registered email

Or Login with

Sign In with google

Sign up to CarWale

Please enter your name
+91
Please enter your mobile number
Please enter your password
Please enter your password
Ad

Maruti Suzuki WagonR AMT vs Hyundai Santro AMT

Introduction

Maruti Suzuki WagonR AMT vs Hyundai Santro AMT

With our cities getting crowded and traffic congestion increasing, driving is getting difficult with each passing day. The need for an automatic has grown over the years, especially in bumper-to-bumper traffic when one has to constantly press the clutch and shift gears. Small wonder then that cars with automated manual transmission (AMT) have gained so much of popularity. One, for the ease it provides with clutchless gearshifts and two, for being far more affordable than conventional automatic gearboxes. Pair this with an entry-level hatchback and it addresses all the afore-mentioned worries that come with a family car. This formula has definitely worked and is now being used in two cars that are now a household name in any Indian family - the Hyundai Santro and the Maruti Suzuki WagonR.

Maruti Suzuki WagonR AMT vs Hyundai Santro AMT

Both monikers are old, but both cars are in their new-gen avatar. They are built on a new platform, boast of a new design, new features, bigger cabin and so much more than their predecessors. Plus, with the availability of an automatic variant, entry-level car buyers are in a dilemma over which one to choose. This is where our extensive road test of these models will give you a clear idea of which one makes a better proposition.

Size and appearance

Maruti Suzuki WagonR AMT vs Hyundai Santro AMT

The WagonR is the newer car that was launched this year. It's completely new from the ground-up, and yet manages to retain the WagonR's original avatar. That said it's not boxy. In fact, its rounded edges making it a fairly good-looking car. In its third-generation, it’s built on a new platform and is bigger and better than its outgoing model. Its front end sports a new grille along with nicely shaped headlamps and a new bumper with a trapezoidal housing for the fog lamps. The rear too benefits from a complete re-jig as well, with new elongated tail lamps giving it a modern and mature look.

Maruti Suzuki WagonR AMT vs Hyundai Santro AMT

The Santro, on the other hand, was launched last year, marking its comeback after it was first launched 20 years ago in India. It’s bigger than the outgoing model, but still smaller in dimensions than the WagonR. In terms of design, the swept-back headlamps, large grille, a tall-boy stance and uninteresting rear don't add that much flair. And despite the flared wheel arches and creases on the body, there isn’t anything that makes it look very attractive.

Cabin Comfort and Space

Maruti Suzuki WagonR AMT

Still, compared to the original Santro, this new one has a larger cabin thanks to its new platform. In fact, at the time of its launch, it was the most spacious car in its class. But then, the new Wagon R is now built on the Heartect platform, which also underpins the Baleno and the Swift, making the car bigger in terms of dimensions and space. This translates into great headroom inside the cabin although the Santro’s is still respectable. Both cars don’t get seat height adjustment. Yet, Hyundai hasn’t equipped it with an adjustable steering wheel, meaning tall people are going to have trouble finding the perfect driving position. That’s not the case with the Maruti, although, with steering that can be adjusted for rake. A large glasshouse in both cars provides a good view of the road ahead. Only the rearward visibility in the Santro is hampered owing to the smaller rear windscreen.

Hyundai Santro AMT

The front seats are accommodating and nicely contoured providing adequate support. Hyundai has paired the fabric material with rexine to give it a more upmarket feel. An ergonomically laid out dashboard with quirky looking ac vents and a large touch screen means that even the controls are within arm’s reach. Meanwhile, the WagonR’s cabin also has a decent design, but the hard plastics, the texture, finesse and the feel aren’t as good as the quality of materials used in the Santro. In the latter, it feels so much better, in fact, similar to cars from a higher segment, like the Grand i10. We still would have liked the placement of switches for power windows in the conventional door-pads instead of the centre console.

Maruti Suzuki WagonR AMT

Moreover, storage places are sufficient in both cars with decently sized glove-boxes, four bottle holders and smartly managed stowage slots in the dashboard and centre console. In the back seat, one might think that the Santro’s roof sloping backwards might hinder the rear headroom. Of course, it isn’t as generous as the WagonR but ample enough for average heighted individuals. Surely, the Maruti with more headroom, shoulder room and knee room is more spacious than the Santro and compliant for three occupants. Yet, the Santro’s seats are nicely inclined, provide more thigh support and the beige door pads give it a roomier feel. What’s more, the rear ac vents are a first-in-segment feature which add to the comfort. Still the WagonR beats the Santro in the boot space department with 106 litres of additional boot space. It also gets a split-fold seat adding to the versatility.

Hyundai Santro AMT

Decked up?

Maruti Suzuki WagonR AMT

Gone are the days when creature comforts could only be found in cars from the higher segment. Now entry-level cars also boast of equipment for comfort, safety, convenience and infotainment needs. Both these cars are no different. Most notable is the new infotainment system previously unseen on any Maruti. This SmartPlay Studio system has an easy-to-use and nice-looking interface supporting Android Auto and Apple CarPlay. Sure, the Santro’s touch screen might not be as colourful as the home screen on the WagonR, but it does support Mirrorlink.

Hyundai Santro AMT

The other bits are common like central door locking, power windows, electrically adjustable ORVMs, a comprehensive trip computer, steering mounted audio controls, USB, 12V charging ports amongst others. In fact, the WagonR also gets an external boot-release. Still one thing that left us wanting for more in both cars is the option of alloy wheels. Nonetheless, safety wise, both cars are equipped with a driver-side airbag. And yet, the WagonR surpasses it with an additional passenger side airbag and rear parking sensors.

On the road

Maruti Suzuki WagonR AMT

The biggest change in the new Wagon R is a four-cylinder 1.2-litre petrol engine offered for the first time along-side the already existing three-cylinder 1.0-litre engine option. Here, this 1.2-litre motor churns out 82bhp and 113Nm of torque as compared to its 1.0-litre counterpart producing 67bhp and 90Nm. Both engines are mated to a five-speed gearbox with the option of AMT. On the other hand, the Santro comes powered by a heavily reworked version of the Santro Xing’s 1.1-litre, four-cylinder Epsilon petrol engine that offers 69bhp and 99Nm of torque in its current guise. Apart from a five-speed manual, one may avail of this five-speed AMT, which marks the debut of AMT technology for Hyundai.

Hyundai Santro AMT

Both the engines are equally silent, however, the Santro’s unit feels more refined. Moreover, its engine noise doesn’t filter into the cabin. That said, it gets quite audible in both cars post 4,000rpm. Now as on paper, the difference in the power also clearly shows right when you get off the mark. The WagonR feels quicker and the extra power helps it get going faster than the Santro. Both take their sweet time at low rpms but it’s in the mid-range where the WagonR feels stronger. Comparatively, the Santro’s engine feels like it needs to be worked upon a bit to squeeze out performance from it. But it’s probably because Hyundai has tuned the motor to be energy efficient over everything else. But does it make up for a lot of ground? We will get to that in our fuel efficiency tests.

Maruti Suzuki WagonR AMT

Now, let’s get to the AMT gearboxes. They undoubtedly provide relief in traffic snarls. Both cars move ahead smoothly as soon as you let go off the brakes, but the WagonR has a stronger tug. The Santro’s AMT still offers relatively smooth gearshifts. In the WagonR, the head nod on gear-shifts is pronounced, whereas this has been contained well in the Santro, resulting in a smoother drive. Comparatively, the WagonR’s gearbox is more responsive and doesn’t require the need to shift manually at times as in the Santro. That said, both feel a bit slow on open roads whether it’s for upshifting or downshifting. This is a characteristic AMT trait where it takes a bit of time to recognise driver’s input. Still one has the option of changing gears manually, which will help in getting more control while going down a slope or planning to overtake.

For the ride and handling bit, both these cars with a tall-boy design have a compact footprint ideal for city dwellings. And though these are not really fun to chuck around corners, both are predictable handlers with light steering. These weigh up adequately at high speeds, still, the artificial response in the Santro hampers the feel. The WagonR feels better with a more fluid and smooth response. Unlike the Hyundai which feels more planted, Maruti’s hatchback is taller and hence the body roll in the latter is more pronounced too. Suspension duties are done by McPherson struts upfront and torsion beams at the rear, which are nicely tuned to absorb shocks, especially to iron out road imperfections. That said, the Santro’s set-up manages to absorb shocks better, especially sharper potholes and road joints. But when you pick up the pace, the soft tuning makes for a springy ride that gets uncomfortable for rear passengers. The WagonR, on the other hand, is relatively stiffer and provides a flatter ride at higher speeds. There’s no particular difference on the braking front and both cars have enough stopping power and tyre grip with similar profiles of wheels and rubber.

Maruti Suzuki WagonR AMT vs Hyundai Santro AMT

Acceleration and in-gear tests

Maruti Suzuki WagonR AMT vs Hyundai Santro AMT

According to our VBOX figures, the Santro took a lazy 17.64 seconds to complete the 0-100kmph run, while the WagonR did it in just 13.94 seconds. And again, when it came to the crucial test of driveability, the Maruti won in the roll-ons too. The 20-80kmph in kick-down was completed 1.97 seconds faster and similarly it was quicker by 2.62 seconds in the 40-100kmph run. This clearly goes to show the difference in the pulling power of the two cars. Meaning the WagonR will overtake quickly, all thanks to the extra power and lighter weight.

Maruti Suzuki WagonR AMT vs Hyundai Santro AMT

Fuel efficiency

Maruti Suzuki WagonR AMT vs Hyundai Santro AMT

Fuel efficiency figures in real world conditions vary from the ARAI-claimed numbers. Yet we tested both these cars in the same conditions and results show a very small difference. The Santro returned 11.41kmpl in the city with the WagonR not too far behind at 10.69kmpl. Interestingly, it's the Maruti Suzuki that returned 19.41kmpl on the highway, better than the Hyundai trailing at 17.7kmpl.

Maruti Suzuki WagonR AMT vs Hyundai Santro AMT

Verdict

Maruti Suzuki WagonR AMT vs Hyundai Santro AMT

Rank 2 Hyundai Santro Sportz AMT

Final Score – 361

Price – Rs 6.44 lakhs (on-road Mumbai)

Maruti Suzuki WagonR AMT vs Hyundai Santro AMT

Even though the Santro might not be very good-looking but is still a good overall package. It’s impressive with its interior design, segment-first features, better quality interiors, refined engine and a smoother gearbox. Still, it couldn’t match up to the performance and interior space of the WagonR.

Rank 1 Maruti Suzuki WagonR ZXi AMT

Final Score – 375

Price – Rs 6.79 lakhs (on-road Mumbai)

Maruti Suzuki WagonR AMT vs Hyundai Santro AMT

The WagonR wins this test by a good margin because of its better engine performance and larger cabin. Sure it could do with a better NVH cabin insulation and better use of plastics inside. But other than that it’s hard to find fault with. Its price is also justified for the extra features and safety equipment. And how can we forget Maruti’s brand and resale value? Needless to say, if you had to choose between the two, we think you should make space for the WagonR in your parking lot.

Pictures by Kapil Angane

Specifications

CAR NAME Maruti Suzuki WagonR Hyundai Santro
Variant ZXi AMT
Sportz AMT
ENGINE
Fuel Petrol Petrol
Installation Front, transverse Front, transverse
Displacement 1197cc, 4 cyls 1086cc, 4 cyls
Power 82bhp at 6,000rpm 68bhp at 5,500rpm
Torque 113Nm at 4,200rpm 99Nm at 4,500rpm
Power to weight 96.47bhp per tonne  74.72bhp per tonne 
Torque to weight 132.94Nm per tonne 108.79Nm per tonne
Gearbox 5-speed AMT 5-speed AMT
CHASSIS & BODY
Kerb weight 850kg 910kg
Tyres 165/70 R14 165/70 R14
Spare Full size Full size
STEERING
Type Rack and pinion Rack and pinion
Type of assist Electric Electric
Turning circle 9.4m 9.6m
BRAKES
Front Discs Discs
Rear Drums Drums
Anti-lock No No

Test Data

CAR NAME Maruti Suzuki WagonR Hyundai Santro
Variant ZXi AMT Sportz AMT
PERFORMANCE & BRAKING
0-20kmph - -
0-40kmph 3.8s 3.63s
0-60kmph 6.19s 7.39s
0-80kmph 9.84s 12.11s
0-100kmph 13.94s 17.64s
0-120kmph 20.44s 27.67s
20-80kmph in 3rd gear (kickdown) 8.23s 10.20s
40-100kmph in 4th gear (kickdown) 10.03s 12.65s
80-0kmph 27.44m 28.99m
FUEL ECONOMY
City 10.69kmpl 11.41kmpl
Highway 19.41kmpl 17.7kmpl
Tank size 32 litres 35 litres
Range 403.96m 431.98km
INTERIOR MEASUREMENTS
Front
Legroom(Max/min) 860/630mm 820/650mm
Headroom 960mm 990mm
Shoulder room 1280mm 1270mm
Backrest height 580mm 600mm
Rear
Legroom(Max/min) 850/650mm 820/630mm
Ideal legroom 630mm 720mm
Headroom 920mm 940mm
Shoulder room 1320mm 1240mm
Seat base length 480mm 490mm
Backrest height 670mm 610mm
Boot 341 litres 250 litres
Length/width/height 660/1050/630mm 580/1050/530mm
Loading lip height 760mm 760mm

Score Sheet

Parameters Max points

Maruti Suzuki WagonR AMT

Hyundai Santro AMT

DRIVING FEEL
Steering response 20 11 10
Directional stability 25 13 15
Engine characteristics 25 15 14
Gearbox 20 14 15
Visibility 10 7 7
Intermediate results 100 60 61
SPACE
Front Space 25 13 13
Rear space 25 16 12
Feeling of space 20 13 13
Boot space/flexibility 20 12 9
Payload 10 5 5
Intermediate results 100 59 52
IN THE CABIN
Comfort equipment 25 7 7
Operatibility 15 9 9
Feel of quality 20 12 13
Front seats/ingress 20 14 14
Rear seat/ingress 20 14 13
Intermediate results 100 56 56
PERFORMANCE
Acceleration 25 14 11
Top speed 10 6 6
Driveability 30 33 27
Braking 25 19 18
Environment 10 6 6
Intermediate results 100 78 68
ROAD MANNERS
Ride quality 30 19 20
Turning circle 15 14 14
Handling 20 11 10
Manoeuvrability 15 12 12
Safety 20 4 3
Intermediate results 100 60 59
PRICE
Price 45 30 37
Resale 10 7 7
Warranty 10 5 7
Fuel efficiency 35 20 20
Intermediate results 100 62 65
Total 600 375 361

Photos

Ad

Maruti Suzuki Wagon R Price in India

CityOn-Road Prices
New Delhi₹ 4.83 Lakhs onwards
Kolkata₹ 4.92 Lakhs onwards
Chennai₹ 5.11 Lakhs onwards
Hyderabad₹ 5.19 Lakhs onwards
Mumbai₹ 5.15 Lakhs onwards
Bangalore₹ 5.3 Lakhs onwards
  • Upcoming Cars

Hyundai Kona EVHyundai Kona EV

9th Jul 2019

25L - ₹ 30L
MG HectorMG Hector

Jun 2019

18L - ₹ 23L
Volkswagen Next Generation VentoVolkswagen Next Generation Vento

Jul 2019

8L - ₹ 14L
BMW New 3 SeriesBMW New 3 Series

Jul 2019

50L - ₹ 60L
Renault TriberRenault Triber

Unveils on : Jun 2019

5L - ₹ 7L
All Upcoming Cars

Tips, Advice & Guides

Car tips, advice & guides from our experts

Tips & Advice 
Ad

MG Hector

India’s First Internet Car

MG HectorTest Drive Now

Select your city to avail offers

Currently available only in