CarWale
    AD

    Simply the best car for city driving, irrespective of how much you are willing to pay

    5 years ago | Tanmay

    User Review on Tata Nano GenX XTA

    Detail Review:
    Rating parameters
    (out of 5)

    5.0

    Exterior

    5.0

    Comfort

    4.0

    Performance

    4.0

    Fuel Economy

    5.0

    Value for Money

    PURCHASE:
    Used

    DRIVING:
    Few hundred kilometers

    Recently bought Nano automatic. Although I have Figo and Ecosport automatic, Nano is my favorite for city drive. Nano story would be remembered in management books as greatest case study where an engineering marvel was made to fail by wrong marketing campaigns.

    Entire focus of Nano marketing was on getting two wheeler users to upgrade to Nano. Why would they, when they can simply afford a bigger second hand car.

    Nano is not best suited for first time car buyers as its suited for second car buyers.

    There is no better car than Nano automatic in Indian market for city traffic conditions. I relish it every Day as it helps me save about 15 min on my 20km city traffic drive. But I feel sorry for Ratan Tata and other Nano engineers whose great efforts failed due to wrong product positioning by Nano marketing team. Here is what I love about Nano

    1. Small Width - Helps me squeeze through leftmost part of road and narrow road conditions due to illegal parking, people occupying multiple lanes to turn right on signal, metro work.

    2. Small length - Very easy to park in remaining space between a parked car and open gate where most bigger/longer cars can't fit. I call them exclusive Nano parking spots.

    3. Big Window - Tall seating and large windows make minimize visual obstructions while driving/riding. Feels like you are on bike but without the noise and pollution of road.

    4. Right pickup for city conditions - Nano automatic in sport mode has just the right pickup for city driving conditions which allows you to go into those open gaps between cars without making it too much where you need to immediately apply breaks.

    5. Good AC - AC is very powerful and even in peak Hyd summer, I can't keep it on max cool for too long as it gets very cold.

    6. Tall Seating- Tall seating is more comfortable, gives better view of the road and getting in and out is easy. I hate getting in and out of sedan and hatchbacks.

    7. Power Steering- Very light and easy to operate with one hand in traffic. 

    8. Speakers- Good car speakers.

    9. No big bonnet- You have perfect judgement of road ahead, making it easy to move across lanes when you are stuck in traffic.

    10. High ground clearance- Those bad roads and rough side patches are no concern when driving nano due to its 180mm and short wheelbase.

    11. Sport mode- This is the mode for regular car driving. Economy is only for mileage fans. Some negatives.

    1. Car Bluetooth Microphone - Peaks up lot of noise and people on other side can't hear clearly. I use a portable bose speaker with microphone.

    2. Image - Thanks to Tata's Marketing geniuses, this car has so poor image that people feel it's weird to drive this car. I know people in Bangalore who want this comfort but buy Mahindra E2O over this car due to image issue.

    3. Don't make a turn in it at high speed, it may topple. I met a guy whose nano toppled during a steep turn on highway exit

    Overall - If you already have a car / SUV etc but tired of driving it and looking for something in city driving conditions, look no further. There is no better alternative in market irrespective of how much you are ready pay. Best part is, most fantastic car for city driving is cheapest car to own as well.

    Some requests to Tata Motors:

    1. Please release new version with following features a. Better sound insulation b. Android auto & apple carplay (lift and shift from Nexon) like Renault did it. We should be able to take conf calls from car. c. Front hand rest.

    2. Fire your current marketing team and start a fresh marketing campaign focused on second car buyers who need car for city use. Focus on easy of parking and livability and how it's better than bigger cars instead of focusing on how it's better than bike. Work hard to improve image of car.

    3. Reduce the price by at-least 50k.

    4. Add reverse parking camera with dashcam as dealer side accessory. 3k worth of accessory makes it very useful.

    Size, Size and SizeImage
    Was this review helpful?
    Like Button
    1
    DisLike Button
    0
    More User Reviews
    5 years ago | Aakash Roy
    Was this review helpful?
    Like Button
    0
    DisLike Button
    0
    5 years ago | Vishwa
    Was this review helpful?
    Like Button
    1
    DisLike Button
    0
    5 years ago | Deepak Thomas
    Was this review helpful?
    Like Button
    0
    DisLike Button
    0
    6 years ago | Navin Kumar
    Was this review helpful?
    Like Button
    0
    DisLike Button
    0
    6 years ago | Prashant
    Was this review helpful?
    Like Button
    0
    DisLike Button
    0

    Reviews you may also consider

    AD
    Write Review
    Write a detailed review of a car and you can
    scissors image
    Win Amazon Voucher worth
     ₹
    2000

    Want to read the reviews for any other car?