CarWale
    AD

    not up to the expectations

    14 years ago | Rajendra Acharya

    User Review on Tata Manza [2011-2015] Aqua Quadrajet BS-III

    Detail Review:
    Rating parameters
    (out of 5)

    3.0

    Exterior

    3.0

    Comfort

    3.0

    Performance

    4.0

    Fuel Economy

    4.0

    Value for Money

    PURCHASE:
    Not Purchased

    DRIVING:

    I got a call from Concord motors chennai for a test drive, with my busy schedule I could take half day on a working day for the test drive( un like others TATA 's dont work on Sundays ), along with my family. I hold a maruti Alto which is 3 yrs old and I would like to go for sedan.

    I had lot of expectation from tata maanza. I got the test drive after a waiting for 45 minutes at the show room The good thing in this car is NVH level. I did not feel whether the engine is started or not. Cabin noise is so low. As I moved on to the main Road ( velechery Road) I started realising some facts. Third gear is really good. But the as i accelerated I foud the response was not rocky. I had test driven Ford IKON and i 20 diesel version. I understand why TATA is failing repeatedly for a well designed passenger car.

    cr is not so attractive from inside and out side too. Though it is filled with all the features what I could feel is TATA has incorporated just for the sake of it, but quality is horrible. over all I was not happy witht he performance. I delayed my decision to buy a sedan for six months thinking TATA maanza could meet my expectations. But utilimately I am disappointed.

    On the way back to my home I just entered INDUS motors for taking a final decesion on my DEZIRE. Lucky enough to get the test drive immediately. Over all car is far supeior compare to Maanza in all respects. My observations on various cars based on test drives:

    had a test drive of following diesel cars. my experience:
    1. Ford Ikon: great strudy car , very good power AC so chilling,. Interiors / AC vents not so appealing, noisy engine. VFM.
    2. Hyundai i 20: Excellant car with great features. Pick up is excellant. interiors also good. But no VFM., AC not so effective

    3. Indigo Maanza : bad car, but VFM., engine lag too much, not good for city, low pick up, plastic quality is cheap., filled with feature.

    4. Swift dezire: good engine, good features, great car.

    planning to Book a Dezire VDI shortly.

    Friends.., please give your feed back who are using the above and help me to take a corect decision,

    less pricebad and cramoy interiors
    Was this review helpful?
    Like Button
    8
    DisLike Button
    12
    More User Reviews
    14 years ago | Pankaj Kumar
    Was this review helpful?
    Like Button
    16
    DisLike Button
    18
    14 years ago | Sujay Kumar Roy
    Was this review helpful?
    Like Button
    65
    DisLike Button
    1
    Was this review helpful?
    Like Button
    56
    DisLike Button
    2
    Was this review helpful?
    Like Button
    3
    DisLike Button
    10
    14 years ago | Anurag Setia
    Was this review helpful?
    Like Button
    21
    DisLike Button
    1

    Reviews you may also consider

    AD
    Write Review
    Write a detailed review of a car and you can
    scissors image
    Win Amazon Voucher worth
     ₹
    2000

    Want to read the reviews for any other car?