CarWale
    AD

    Toyota Innova Crysta Automatic vs Mahindra XUV500 Automatic

    Authors Image

    Sagar Bhanushali

    56,484 Views

    Introduction

    What you see here are two rather different takes on comfortable long-distance workhorses.

    In the purple corner we have Toyota’s new Innova Crysta Automatic, a stonking big people carrier that leans on the legendarily reliable status of the original model. Serving a similar recipe in the white corner is the Mahindra XUV500 Automatic which is about the same size but dons the high-riding look of a typical SUV.

    Why pit them against each other? Simple, both are different responses to a question often asked nowadays. That question usually goes like, “I’ve Rs 20-odd lakh to spend on a large 7-seater automatic car. What are my options?” Time to figure out the apt response…

    Solid road presence

    On the surface, the Innova Crysta and the XUV500 couldn’t have looked any more different (both belong to different spheres of the utility segment, after all). While the Toyota represents an aggressive yet stylish take on the full-size MPV space, the Mahindra has crossover design cues all over it. Naturally, the latter has a more impactful stance thanks to its towering height and massively beefed up wheel arches. The XUV, then, is big, brawny and everything a typical Indian looks for in a large crossover.

    The Innova Crysta, on the other hand, has freshly arrived and accordingly looks new age. As far as generation changes go, the Crysta is a far cry from the old model, especially the front-end look. Gone is the old meek and boring looking fascia and in its place is a design which is a lot more expressive, thanks to a large hexagonal grille and the twin-slat chrome grille that merges neatly into the headlamps. Now although these upgrades have added fair bit of muscle to the van-like proportions, it’s no secret that it would still be difficult for the Innova to be as desirable as the XUV in the eyes of the SUV-favouring janata.

    Practical insides

    Inside the Innova Crysta, everything from the design, layout and the material has changed for the good, well nearly. Yes, the dashboard is more cluttered than before but there is no denying that it’s thoroughly modern and pleasing to look at. The centre console is dominated by a 7-inch display integrated nicely into the layout and sitting atop a neat series of knobs and buttons for the climate control. In terms of quality, all the buttons and dials have a tactile feel and the leather-wrapped steering wheel feels great to hold as well. What also come as a neat touch are the softly padded door armrests and the sun visors.

    Next to the new Innova, the XUV’s interior is less pleasing to the eye. It looks up to date nonetheless and the blend of black and beige upholstery works well in adding to the overall sense of space. What lets the cabin down though are the low-grade plastics on contact points like the door pads and the air vents. That said, fit and finish on both these vehicles is only above average. While the Toyota’s cabin feels sturdy and rugged, it is plagued with a couple of ill-fitting bits like the dash-mounted cup holders and the flimsy glove box opening switch. Worse still, the XUV feels more utilitarian as some of the dash plastics simply do not feel apt for a vehicle costing upwards of Rs 20 lakh.

    That aside, both are evenly matched when it comes to technology and connectivity. There’s touchscreen audio system with Bluetooth, electrically adjustable driver’s seat, climate control, electrically foldable mirrors and lots more as standard on both the cars. All said and listed, it’s the Innova that impresses more with extra features like 7 airbags (as opposed to 6 in the XUV), better quality leather seats, start-stop button and a neatly integrated multi information display. Toyota, however, has skimped on rear disc brakes and sunroof – features that are available on the XUV.

    From the driver’s seat, both offer impressive forward and rearward visibility though again, it’s the Innova that nails the comfort brief better than the XUV. Given the automatic nature of these cars, buyers are expected to spend a fair bit of time in the front and in here, it’s the Innova that treats its occupants better with a more supportive seat and heaps of adjustment for the steering wheel and the seat. Move onto the rear and things are evenly matched as the rear seats on both the vehicles are fully supportive with adequate under thigh support and a cabin wide enough to seat three adults comfortably. That said, you cannot have three occupants in this top-spec Z variant which gets captain seats.

    The second row of the Toyota offers extra versatility with the sliding function for better access to the third row. Speaking of which, the third row seating in neither of these vehicles is good enough to accommodate two adults. The combination of a high floor and low seat means you end up sitting in a cramped manner with your knees locked in. For comparison’s sake, the Innova happens to have more knee room and bigger seats in the third row but frankly things are still pretty tight for your average size occupant.

    In the overall scheme of things, the Innova Crysta takes the win for interior design, versatility and quality.

    Automatic equals convenience

    The Innova Crysta Automatic uses an entirely new ladder-frame chassis and is powered by a 174bhp/360Nm 2.8-litre, four-cylinder diesel engine. Whereas the XUV500 is more car-like, using a monocoque construction and transverse engine layout. It’s also got a much smaller capacity engine i.e. a 140bhp/330Nm 2.2-litre unit. As for the crux of this test, both these vehicles make use of a 6-speed automatic gearbox. More on that later…

    Looking at the displacement, it doesn’t take long to find out that the Innova’s powertrain is more capable and surprisingly better refined, too. That said, the latter trait has a lot to do with the fact that the Innova is very well insulated.

    The engine’s extra torque low down and in the mid-range makes it more effortless to get up to speed than the XUV. Despite the XUV’s more average output, the 2.2-litre engine remains pretty strong. It has no trouble pulling this from slow to medium speeds.The Innova does 0-100kmph in 11.67 seconds while the less powerful XUV takes around 0.2 seconds more at 11.92. Our tests also reveal the Toyota to be quicker under roll-on acceleration from 40-100kmph, taking 8.56 seconds compared to 9.32 seconds taken by the XUV. This is down to the quicker-shifting 6-speed unit in the Innova. It’s fairly quick and responsive when you are in a hurry and need to reel in that gap in traffic and smooth enough to waft along and cruise at par throttle. In fact, on part throttle it upshifts fairly early and uses the substantial torque of the diesel engine to make quick progress. This gearbox really allows the Innova to stretch its legs out on the highway, thanks to the tall fifth and sixth ratios. Cruising at triple digits speeds with the engine hovering at just 1,600rpm, the Innova Crysta is quite the long-distance hauler.

    The 6-speeder in the XUV500 is on the lazier side and relies more on the engine’s pulling power than responding quicker but the way it works through the gears is just as smooth as the Toyota. It works best on part throttle where it upshifts at around 2,500rpm, using the engine’s wide torque spread to its advantage. Due to the relaxed nature of the gearbox and the power deficit, the XUV needs more time to make an overtake, while the more powerful (though heavier) Innova feels more flexible and willing to keep accelerating.

    The Innova may be quicker of the two; however, around town it’s quite a handful. It uses a hydraulically assisted steering rack which is heavy and can be vague at times. The XUV’s steering in comparison is fairly light and makes driving at slow speeds easy and carefree. As for the ride quality, at slow speeds the Innova feels more planted partially due to its inherent refinement – it just feels like it’s put together more tightly. By contrast the XUV feels brittle over rough roads. What adds to the impressive low speed comfort in the Toyota is the better insulation from the tyres, the suspension and engine noise. All that said, the XUV has a few neat tricks up its flared wheel arches that outshine the Innova. Being 40kilos lighter (despite the full load of its giant 70-litre fuel tank), its more agile during turn in and its steering feel is nicer as well.

    The Innova’s low-speed ride may offer an extra layer of cushioning from small bumps, but up the pace over undulated roads and its reactions differ from the SUV. Whereas the latter settles quicker and remains more composed, the equally stiff Innova starts to wallow and ride a little pitchy over the same bumps.

    Verdict

    Mahindra XUV500 Automatic

    Price- Rs 20.44 lakh (OTR, Mumbai)

    Rank -2nd

    Final Score – 367/600

    “I’ve Rs 20-odd lakh to spend on a large automatic car. What are my options?”

    That’s the question we set out to respond. And a clear answer to that would eventually come down to what’s more important to the individual buyer. The XUV500 Automatic, for instance, has got a broad-shouldered road presence, lengthy equipment list and of course, that much needed blend of a smooth shifting automatic gearbox and light steering to make life easier. At Rs 20.44 lakh, it's not exactly what you would call good value, but next to the Innova it’s safe to say it represents a really good bargain. The XUV, then, is a benchmark-setting choice in many ways although it still lags behind the Innova Crysta on key parameters like interior quality, versatility and the drivetrain.

    Toyota Innova Crysta Automatic

    Price- Rs 25.78 lakh (OTR, Mumbai)

    Rank -1st

    Final Score – 385/600

    This brings us to the Innova Crysta, which claims a convincing win in this test.

    While it isn’t perfect, being much more expensive to buy and insure and with a high speed ride that jiggly, the Innova Crysta is a brilliant product otherwise. It’s more refined and versatile than the XUV, well put together, packed to the brim with electronic goodies and, crucially, is in for a real shout of being endlessly reliable in the long run.

    Photos by Kapil Angane

    Click here to read our comprehensive road test of the Toyota Innova Crysta

    Click here to read our first drive report of the Mahindra XUV500 Automatic

    Specification

    CAR NAME Toyota Innova Crysta Mahindra XUV500
    Variant ZX 2.8 AT W10 AT
    ENGINE
    Fuel Diesel Diesel
    Installation Front, transverse Front, transverse
    Displacement 4 cyls, 2795cc 4 cyls, 2179cc
    Power 174bhp at 3400rpm 138bhp at 3750rpm
    Torque 360nm at 1200-3400rpm 330Nm at 1600rpm
    Power to weight 93.04bhp per tonne 75.61bhp per tonne
    Torque to weight 192.51Nm per tonne 180.82Nm per tonne
    Gearbox 6-speed automatic 6-speed automatic
    CHASSIS & BODY
    Kerb weight 1880kg 1840kg
    Tyres 215/55 R17 235/65 R17
    Spare Full-size Full-size
    STEERING
    Type Rack and pinion Rack and pinion
    Type of assist Hydraulic Hydraulic
    Turning circle 10.80m 11.20m
    BRAKES
    Front Discs Discs
    Rear Drums Discs
    Anti-lock Yes Yes

    Test Data

    CAR NAME Toyota Innova Crysta Mahindra XUV500
    Variant ZX 2.8 AT W10 AT
    PERFORMANCE & BRAKING
    0-20kmph 1.01s 1.08s
    0-40kmph 2.69s 2.93s
    0-60kmph 4.81s 5.29s
    0-80kmph 7.74s 8.08s
    0-100kmph 11.67s 11.92s
    0-120kmph 16.63s 17.03s
    20-80kmph in 3rd gear (kickdown) 6.73s 6.75s
    40-100kmph in 4th gear (kickdown) 8.56s 9.32s
    80-0kmph 25.45m 27.55m
    FUEL ECONOMY
    City 9.80kmpl 9.40kmpl
    Highway 13.90kmpl 13.81kmpl
    Tank size 55 litres 70 litres
    Range 556km 690km
    INTERIOR MEASUREMENTS
    Front
    Legroom(Max/min) 820/610mm 890/640mm
    Headroom 1020mm 960mm
    Shoulder room 1460mm 1470mm
    Backrest height 630mm 600mm
    Rear
    Legroom(Max/min)

    1010/760mm

    900/670mm
    Ideal legroom 830mm 790mm
    Headroom 1020mm 960mm
    Shoulder room 1460mm 1460mm
    Seat base length 490mm 480mm
    Backrest height 630mm 600mm
    Boot 983 litres 570 litres
    Length/width/height 1210/1270/640mm 850/1200/480mm
    Loading lip height 710mm 750mm

    Score sheet

    Parameters Max points

    Toyota Innova Crysta

    Mahindra XUV500

    DRIVING FEEL
    Steering response 20 8 9
    Directional stability 25 13 13
    Engine characteristics 25 17 16
    Gearbox 20 13 12
    Visibility 10 7 7
    Intermediate results 100 58 57
    SPACE
    Front Space 25 20 17
    Rear space 25 18 18
    Feeling of space 20 16 15
    Boot space/flexibility 20 20 18
    Payload 10 7 9
    Intermediate results 100 81 77
    IN THE CABIN
    Comfort equipment 25 16 15
    Operatibility 15 11 10
    Feel of quality 20 12 11
    Front seats/ingress 20 16 15
    Rear seat/ingress 20 15 13
    Intermediate results 100 70 64
    PERFORMANCE
    Acceleration 25 17 17
    Top speed 10 8 7
    Driveability 30 24 23
    Braking 25 21 19
    Environment 10 5 4
    Intermediate results 100 75 70
    ROAD MANNERS
    Ride quality 30 20 18
    Turning circle 15 12 12
    Handling 20 10 9
    Manoeuvrability 15 8 9
    Safety 20 12 12
    Intermediate results 100 62 60
    PRICE
    Price 45 8 10
    Resale 10 8 6
    Warranty 10 7 7
    Fuel efficiency 35 16 16
    Intermediate results 100 39 39
    Total 600 385 367

    Featured Cars

    • Popular
    • JUST LAUNCHED
    • Upcoming
    Maruti Suzuki Fronx
    Maruti Fronx
    Rs. 7.51 Lakhonwards
    Avg. Ex-Showroom price
    Show price in my city
    Mahindra Scorpio N
    Mahindra Scorpio N
    Rs. 13.60 Lakhonwards
    Avg. Ex-Showroom price
    Show price in my city
    Tata Nexon
    Tata Nexon
    Rs. 8.15 Lakhonwards
    Avg. Ex-Showroom price
    Show price in my city
    Mahindra Scorpio
    Mahindra Scorpio
    Rs. 13.59 Lakhonwards
    Avg. Ex-Showroom price
    Show price in my city
    Hyundai Creta
    Hyundai Creta
    Rs. 11.00 Lakhonwards
    Avg. Ex-Showroom price
    Show price in my city
    Maruti Suzuki Grand Vitara
    Maruti Grand Vitara
    Rs. 10.76 Lakhonwards
    Avg. Ex-Showroom price
    Show price in my city
    Mahindra Thar
    Mahindra Thar
    Rs. 11.25 Lakhonwards
    Avg. Ex-Showroom price
    Show price in my city
    Tata Punch
    Tata Punch
    Rs. 6.13 Lakhonwards
    Avg. Ex-Showroom price
    Show price in my city
    Lexus LM
    Lexus LM
    Rs. 2.00 Croreonwards
    Avg. Ex-Showroom price
    Show price in my city
    JUST LAUNCHED
    15th MAR
    Hyundai Creta N Line
    Hyundai Creta N Line
    Rs. 16.82 Lakhonwards
    Avg. Ex-Showroom price
    Show price in my city
    JUST LAUNCHED
    11th MAR
    BYD Seal
    BYD Seal
    Rs. 41.00 Lakhonwards
    Avg. Ex-Showroom price
    Show price in my city
    Mercedes-Benz AMG GLE Coupe
    Mercedes-Benz AMG GLE Coupe
    Rs. 1.85 Croreonwards
    Avg. Ex-Showroom price
    Show price in my city
    Mercedes-Benz GLA
    Mercedes-Benz GLA
    Rs. 50.50 Lakhonwards
    Avg. Ex-Showroom price
    Show price in my city
    Porsche Macan Turbo EV
    Porsche Macan Turbo EV
    Rs. 1.65 Croreonwards
    Avg. Ex-Showroom price
    Show price in my city
    Rolls-Royce Spectre
    Rolls-Royce Spectre
    Rs. 7.50 Croreonwards
    Avg. Ex-Showroom price
    Show price in my city
    Tata Punch EV
    Tata Punch EV
    Rs. 10.99 Lakhonwards
    Avg. Ex-Showroom price
    Show price in my city
    Mahindra XUV300 facelift
    Mahindra XUV300 facelift

    Rs. 9.00 - 15.00 LakhEstimated Price

    Mar 2024 (Tentative)Expected Launch

    Get Launch Alert on WhatsApp

    Toyota Urban Cruiser Taisor
    Toyota Urban Cruiser Taisor

    Rs. 12.00 - 16.00 LakhEstimated Price

    3rd Apr 2024Unveil Date

    Get Launch Alert on WhatsApp

    Maruti Suzuki New-gen Swift
    Maruti New-gen Swift

    Rs. 6.50 - 10.00 LakhEstimated Price

    Apr 2024 (Tentative)Expected Launch

    Get Launch Alert on WhatsApp

    MG Gloster facelift
    MG Gloster facelift

    Rs. 40.00 - 45.00 LakhEstimated Price

    Apr 2024 (Tentative)Expected Launch

    Get Launch Alert on WhatsApp

    Force Motors Five-door Gurkha
    Force Motors Five-door Gurkha

    Rs. 15.50 - 16.00 LakhEstimated Price

    May 2024 (Tentative)Expected Launch

    Get Launch Alert on WhatsApp

    Nissan Qashqai
    Nissan Qashqai

    Rs. 25.00 - 30.00 LakhEstimated Price

    May 2024 (Tentative)Expected Launch

    Get Launch Alert on WhatsApp

    Volkswagen ID.4
    Volkswagen ID.4

    Rs. 50.00 - 60.00 LakhEstimated Price

    May 2024 (Tentative)Expected Launch

    Get Launch Alert on WhatsApp

    Skoda Superb
    Skoda Superb

    Rs. 28.00 - 35.00 LakhEstimated Price

    Jun 2024 (Tentative)Expected Launch

    Get Launch Alert on WhatsApp

    AD
    • toyota-cars
    • other brands
    Toyota Urban Cruiser Hyryder
    Toyota Urban Cruiser Hyryder
    Rs. 11.14 Lakhonwards
    Avg. Ex-Showroom price
    Show price in my city
    Toyota Innova Crysta
    Toyota Innova Crysta
    Rs. 19.99 Lakhonwards
    Avg. Ex-Showroom price
    Show price in my city
    Toyota Innova Hycross
    Toyota Innova Hycross
    Rs. 19.77 Lakhonwards
    Avg. Ex-Showroom price
    Show price in my city