You are here : Research » Road Tests » Tata Nano : Small Wonder

Tata Nano first drive : Small Wonder

Nano has cute looks and contemporary styling. Good paint quality and exterior finish.

With the unveiling of the much awaited small car from Tata earlier this evening, the Nano has had more hype and attention from the world media than any other Indian carmaker in the past. When Mr. Ratan Tata committed to making a low cost 100,000/- Rupee car, there was much skepticism. Yes, the Nano really will cost you over the benchmark ‘1 Lakh’, but the fact remains that anyone who has been with developing an automobile or a product ground up, which has such high benchmarks to meet, will agree that Tata has done a fairly good job of sticking to it’s promise.

The Nano, earlier known by code names like the ‘Zing’ or ‘Mint’ just became popularly known as the ‘Tata 1 Lakh car’ Early sketches, drawings and various illustrations, do the Nano no justice. It’s an incredibly contemporary looking car with extremely pleasing styling and there is a certain sportiness to it’s overall stance. It’s oval-ish shape with a wheel at each corner, combined with the overall waistline and rear fender slash, makes the Nano look well balanced and clean. Tata’s signature ‘family tail-lamps’ dominate the rear giving the Nano a mini-Indica look and the nose has the centerline which is part of Tata’s new design theme, first seen on the Indica Vista. The large headlamps are a little reminiscent of the Wagon-R but really do add quite a sparkle to the Nano’s nose.

Tata Motors went through many iterations and full scale mock-ups during the design stage of the car. Tata Motor’s had their objectives clearly cut out for them. The car had to be safe, environmentally friendly, a small foot-print on the road and yet have roomy interiors, minimum driver fatigue, comfortable for four tall adults, low cost of purchase and low cost of ownership and low running costs. With such tall orders, the R&D team really did have their task cut out. At various stages of the metamorphosis Tata considered using plastic panels, cloth doors, no doors(!), only a door on each side, but with Mr. Ratan Tata’s personal involvement with the project and his dream of giving the Indian masses a safe, reliable and efficient form of transport (rather than have a family of four on a two-wheeler), the Nano finally now uses a combination of rolled sections and steel panels for the bodyshell. This gives it rigidity and strength and it can even meet the EU crash norms. The only plastics you’ll find on the car’s exterior are the bumpers and some trim bits, and everything else is sheet metal – well finished at that.

Easy to drive and park, cute and contemporary styling, fantastic interior space

Slightly odd sounding engine note at idle, not enough storage space in the interior, difficult to access boot, some very cheap interior plastic bits, slightly stiff ride quality, brakes feel a tad spongy

Comments on this first drive (Latest 10 are shown)

Binoy Thomas
on 22 Apr, 2009 at 06:37 AM

Welcome to CW!

 

For the intended purpose(that of a city runabout) the Nano does has good luggage carrying capacities-the fron dash bins(two of them are large anough to take a school bag each and the rear will take a standard suitcase vertically).

Ravikanth.L
on 22 Apr, 2009 at 03:34 AM

hi tato nano is good at looking .before nano comes to existance i deside to buy the nano but now i was dropped because of there is no way to carry luggage in nano this is the main drawback in nano.

                         my suggestion is to etended length from half to 1 feet space for luggage then it will become to tata ratan  really great day and sales will raise up what they expected.

Pankaj Prasad
on 06 Apr, 2009 at 10:34 PM

@ Sagar, your query - posted before - has been moved as a new thread & answered - have a look.  Others too will post their opinions/views.  The discussions may be continued there (this thread being a review on Nano).

Ami
on 06 Apr, 2009 at 03:35 PM

Even I wish that the car breaks the 'Reliability Jinx' that Tata always had.

Pankaj Prasad
on 04 Apr, 2009 at 03:09 PM

Please go through this link containing FAQs & Answers on Nano.

Charles
on 04 Apr, 2009 at 04:53 AM

I don't deny that Tata isn't a VW where long-term reliability is concerned, neither am I saying they got it spot on - those indicator stalks are giving me nightmares! But the car is well engineered.

Ami
on 03 Apr, 2009 at 04:46 PM

I would also like to side with Charles. However, looking at the track record of Tata so far, there can be durability/reliability issues like in the case of first Sumo/Indica. (which obviously were solved)

Charles
on 03 Apr, 2009 at 10:56 AM

@Sanjeev: I've been driven around in one by one of the development team's members. He took it to its limits - accelerated around a corner till the limits of grip were exceeded, then lifted off. Braked in a straight line over bumps. Locked the wheels around a turn. Did a lane-change manouevre at 80kph (that reminded me of Merc's first A-Class and the elk test. Remember that one?) I'm still here, and not a scratch on me.

@Binoy: The same gentleman told me that the car is capable of 130kph, they've deliberately geared it to top out at 105kph. I don't think that the wheel bearings will be capable of half the speed that the rest of the parts are capable of.

I think the car's got no 'design flaws'. If you think it does, I'd like to see proof, because what evidence I've got so far leads me to believe that it's well engineered.

Pankaj Prasad
on 01 Apr, 2009 at 09:41 PM

@ Sanjeev, I request if you could please go through this discussion (post #46 onwards) & look at it from the perspective the Nano is for.

Binoy Thomas
on 28 Mar, 2009 at 05:35 AM

20K for heat insulationSurprised

 

Come on!