Posted by
Salil R G
Dear Amit,
I own an i 20 Magna version and I completely second to Mr. Pankaj's observations about i 20....i 20 Asta is was about 60k above Magna's price..think the additional price is justified by essentials like Air bags, Alloy wheels, Fog lamps, rear wiper, Automatic climate control, electricaly operated side mirrors, peppy stearing with audio controls, height adjustable drivers seat, keyless entry with folding key(like skoda keys) and rear spoiler(with a little bit of bargain)....I am a budget guy and m happy with my Magna version....
cheers..
SALIL
I agree with you as well as Pankaj. Our views and opinions are not fixed but they are dynamic and change as we accumulate more real life feedback (experience). Smart people learn from the experience of others rather than to wait for that to happen in their own life. I am not a great believer that everyone should reinvent the wheel. As I mentioned in some other thread, I had an almost head on collision over 3 years ago and I am convinced that I am alive because my car had seatbelt ELR, pretensioners and airbags.
Today, things have changed on Indian roads. Say 20-30 years ago, higher percentage of Ambassadors and Premiers were driven by chauffeurs and traffic was that high and cars were driven at moderate speed, safety issues were not that crucial. Today, most cars are driven by owners and family members and traffic movement is much faster, so need for safety is paramount value. Todays most drivers of luxury B+ segment H/B are professionals, who play bigger role in their family, profession, society and community and well being of few depend on them and life has become more valuable like West. Today, peoples regular commute is longer and they demand more safety, comfort and convenience
About modern cars, there are features which can be added later on by outside vendors and there are features which can only be fitted during manufacturing process to be cost effective. If I was in control, I would have given Magna front seatbelt ELR + pretensioners, rear defogger, ABS and at least one airbag rather than 2-Din CD player. Most car owners fit CD player of their choice anyway from outside. I agree that some luxury features, like ACC, Alloy, stereo control on steering wheel etc. are not must but if they are not there then they are not uxury cars or do they. Maruti 800 is the best VFM but demandd more. I have them all, got used to them and now I feel them as necessity but I don't mind stretching my arms to regulate them. This is true that adding ABS and airbags to any car will add about 30-40 K to production input cost.
I would love to hear from you about your experience with Magna. Is the engine really underpowered, as people say? I hear, i20 is more aerodynamic, so FE and power is quite comparable to i10 Kappa, in spite of weight and size. What is your FE and overall experience.