You are here : Research » User Written Reviews » Fiat Petra D 1.9 ELX PS » Fiat Petra D 1.9 ELX PS Reviews

Under hyped - Under rated - GEM

A Review by Sanjay on Fiat Petra D 1.9 ELX PS
10 March, 2007


Average User Rating :
Model Rating  :   3 reviews
Version Rating:   2 reviews
Write a review
User's Ratings for the car

Style
Comfort
Performance
Value for Money
Fuel Economy
 
Overall
Pros : Sturdy build, good handling & Great VFM
Cons : FIAT dealership & service
Review Popularity

Total Views 2461
People Liked 9
People Disliked 0

The Fiat Petra D would easily be the the most under-rated mid size sedan in the Indian car market today. It is not surprising to not find many reviews in this section as you can hardly spot a single car of this model that too in a densely car populated city like Mumbai.


However this is also a boon for folks who do prefer to be a little different from the crowd.


I actually got this car not out of choice but was passed on one from my Employers - Some Expat decided to pack up and leave after making the Company set him up - - In any case I got a very good deal as it wasn't going to cost me anything except running cost.


I was initially very skeptical and took it with a pinch of salt expecting the worst. The car was 9 months old when I got it and a year has gone by since then ..........


It has been a very very pleasant surprise!!!


Let us start with the Pros-


Exterior Looks  - Its basically a slightly stretched Palio with a boot - which is not too bad. The boot doesnt look as if its been pasted on like in the indigo. The ELX comes with alloy wheels, chrome front grill with logo, blacked out B pillars, Body colored ORVM and door handles etc. It does look a tad dated compared to the latest sedans like Fiesta, Aveo yet it does score higher that Esteem, Ikon, Accent, Indigo etc.


 Interiors - It follows the same lines as the exteriors - Simple lines - nothing exceptional or flashy - but very functional and efficient. Steering wheel and gear shift are leather wrapped. Dashboard is a sea of plastic - but of decent quality. Lots of faux wood panel insert provide a little relief. Switches and levers of good quality. Music system is conveniently placed high above AC vents. AC cooling is very good even in extreme summer.


AC blowers can be operated by a stone age slider switch which is horrible.


Seats are ample. Interior space is really large - probably the best in this class. Doors are also completely upholstered with fabric which gives a nice feel. Boot is huge can take atleast 3 large suitcases easily.


Engine - It a decent diesel burner. Doesnt burn any rubber but reasonable power considering its a oil run machine for city traffic. Highway cruising is also a breeze. 90-110kmh is the best speed to drive at if the roads permit. The Engine is noisy at start but smoothens out after warming up.


Fuel efficiency - I get about 10-11km/lt in Mumbai stop-crawl traffic which is probably the worst in the country. On longer runs on the highway it goes up to 14-16km/lt which is pretty good.


Build quality -It is built like a tank - The sheer amount of steel used makes you feel very secure and also ensures that minor skirmishes that are the city standard dont become expensive tinwork. A simple way of testing this (and I have tried it) is open the hood and feel the weight for a minute. Try it instantly with any other car in the same class - you will be astounded at the difference.


Handling - For all that metal and weight it handles really well. Go into a sharp bend at 100kmh and you will marvel at its composure. Feels always well planted at high speeds. Suspension is  on stiffer side but within acceptable limits. Probably this is what adds to the better control


To sum it up - This is an all rounder with numerous virtues. At a <6lacs price tag, its a winner on just VFM.


So what's wrong then? - it's FIAT!!! The dealership and service are PATHETIC!! The whole xperience of owning this gem is nullified by just visiting them once -  All of them are equally bad. I'm not sure of what fruits have been borne through the alliance with TATA but first hand reports are not too encouraging.


Having owned or driven a host of similar cars - Esteem, Ikon, Accent, Corsa, Indigo -- I feel that this is best bet at the




Was this review helpful to you ? Yes | No

5 Comment(s) on this Review

  1. on 02 Jun, 2007 at 03:27 PM Aashish Singh (New Delhi)

    one of the best comments i have read on a car...........clear crisp and transparent.........way to go man.......enjoy ur ride :-)

  2. on 13 Sep, 2007 at 10:45 PM S.Senthil Kumar

    it's pretty good review and almost conveyed the points which i felt about this car. i recently took a car (3 years old)after 2 months long search and am quiet happy.

  3. on 20 Sep, 2007 at 04:35 PM Baburaj

    I bought a brad new petra diesle 8 months ago. I am pleased with the performance of the vehicle. With the tie up with Tata, the serive has realy improved. I have been using fiat over a decade and I am very happy with Fiat quality and performance and the one I was not very happy was with the fiat dealership attituted which has completely changed after the tie up with Tata. I get around 18+ km per lit in highway and around 13+ in Bangalore citi. I will grade Petra as the best in its class

  4. on 28 May, 2008 at 04:17 PM Phani Rajesh Mullapudi (Bangalore)

    I have been using PetraD from October2006 onwards as the proud Owner. IT an astounding machine at that price range of 6.7 lacs onroad, though not very powerful. I touched a TopSpeed of 158Kmph on the GoldenQuadrilateral Stretch from Vijayawada-Nellore & a high-speed of 140 on the Bangalore-Tumkur-Hiriyur NH4.Done 35000 Kms so far & no issues.

  5. on 17 Dec, 2008 at 01:58 PM Dr Wiliam Thomas

    Yes I agree with Mr Patil,I used to travel 2000-3000- km a month,and i owned esteem and, Honda city 05 model before,and i experiance the joy of driving now,the rear seat comfort is very high above than the above said cars for my wife and children.Iam getting max 17.5 -19.5 (70-80 km/hr)in highways with AC and 13.5-14.5 with AC in city.i brought this car as second hand car at 50000 km crossed and now i crossed 10000 now,and a very happy owner,but spares are expensive

Write Your Comment

Please Note: Please be nice, don't be personal in any given cirumstances. If you don't like the review or you think that the information provided is inappropriate, use Report Abuse link just below the review, CarWale.com administrators will take care of it. Any personal attack, harsh comment, abuse or any other kind of offensive comment will be deleted immediately.


Maximum Characters : 4000

Enter the code shown above (If you can't read it: )
Your Email


What's Next
Write your own review Research Petra D at CarWale.com
Sell your Petra D at CarWale.com Read forum discussions for Petra D
Buy used Petra D Read blog posts for Petra D