You are here : Research » User Written Reviews » Maruti Suzuki Swift VDi (Diesel) » Maruti Suzuki Swift VDi (Diesel) Reviews

Drives like a dream - Swift VDi - rules the road

A Review by Bhaskar Deva on Maruti Suzuki Swift VDi (Diesel)
06 July, 2008 (Last Updated: 06 July, 2008)


Average User Rating :
Model Rating  :   132 reviews
Version Rating:   34 reviews
Write a review
User's Ratings for the car

Style
Comfort
Performance
Value for Money
Fuel Economy
 
Overall
Pros : Out of the box Looks, Fuel Economy, OOMPH Factor, Low Maintenance, Ride Quality
Cons : Low quality plastic interiors, fragile bumpers, a tad bit stiff suspension & cabin noise
Review Popularity

Total Views 805
People Liked 0
People Disliked 0
After much researching, finally got my hands on the beauty - Swift VDi is all
shining armor. First look and you know this is the car for me and once I test
drove it, fell in love with it. Booked mine on 9th June 2008 and got the
delivery within 9 days on 18th June 2008.


Dealer: Rohan, Noida

The folks@ Rohan were a little careless and did not pay attension however the
sales exective was very helpful and kind, he ensured that I would get the car
within 10 days and so I did. Glad I didn’t have to wait like the rest.

Cost: 5.63L on Road

First Feel: Being my first Car, I took great pleasure driving my little beatuty out of
the showroom. When I drove it - I could feel the superior Fiat Altec3 Multijet
Engine churn out power under the hood. The 75 horses lives up to my
expectations. The torque on this babe is an amazing 190nm which is far ahead of
the rest in its class.

I had to be very careful when pressing the accelerator - the car simply
wants to take off. The sad part however is that the engineers @ Maruti suggest
you to drive it within 2000rpm or 70kmph for the first 1000kms. So why is it
the sad part??? Well the turbo kicks in @ 2000rpm and then its the open road
and the others cars can get a good good at your car's rear - coz it takes off
totally.

VDi is running one of the most advanced compact diesel engines in the world. As
it features on the Fiat Punto as well in Europe and will be seen in India soon. I
would say the engine noise is surely higher when compared to its Petrol
counterpart(about 15-20% louder) but dont mind that because of the driving
pleasure totally compensates for this. You cant expect to compare a diesel
engine with a pertrol - not happening. My VDi is giving me an amazing 17.5kmpl average
in Delhi with
ac on about 70% of the time. Just for the record - I have clocked just 600 kms
yet. Just waiting for the first service before I take her out on the highway to
end of the road...for a long trip. I was told me that after the first service
the average should touch 19kmpl and after 2nd service - about 20 in city.

Body noise is going to set in
no matter VXi or VDi. But can be fixed on service by putting in dampers etc.

Diesel has its own advantages over petrol:

- its meant to driven longer and at steady speeds without much effect to the
engine (engine is designed to take stress)

- Running cost - though slightly higher than petrol (about 20-25% more than
petrol) however the low fuel costs compensate for it

- Noise is slightly more then petrol but with the ac on and stereo playing
"no difference"

- advantage of Diesel is that it comes packed with a Turbo charger and
intercooler. An awesome multilet common rail diesel engine indeed. Won the
Engine of the yr award in UK 2005. Turbo charger kicks in at 2000rpm and wow is
all I can say. The car feels like a sports car suddenly. Very very peppy and
responsive engine.

- VXi Torque 113nm | VDi torque is a woooping 190nm (you know the difference
when u push the peddle)

- Petrol will give an average of 10-12 in city while the diesel should give
18-20kmpl in city

- Petrol servicing @ 5000 kms. Diesel servicing @ 10,000kms each

For running 1000 kms per month VXi @ 11 kmpl & VDi @ 18 kmpl lets see the
cost difference:

VXi -> (1000/11) x 54 (cost of Premium Petrol@Delhi) = 4909

VDi -> (1000/18) x 37 (cost of Premium Diesel@Delhi) = 2055

Difference: 2853/- Per Month Saving

VDi is 75k more expensive than VXi - Difference in finance amount (loan EMI
per month) is 1688/-

You Save: 1165rs



Now the
best part ->


Standard VDi

Power: 75 bhp

Torque: 190 nm

Top Speed: 170 km/hr

0-100 - 12.5 seconds

With a Pete's Digital Tuning Box (costs
10k in US & 30k in India)

Power goes up to: 92 bhp

Torque goes upto: 212 nm

Top Speed: 192 km/hr

0-100 - 9.5 seconds

Wallah - you cant do this magic with any other car in this segment. Basically
you can beat a Camry with your VDi.



Handling - simply amazing. However I think its good to have 185 tyres with
alloys - improves handling by a good 25%. Cost for Allows + 185 tyres Michelin
should be 22-24k

Cars which featured on my List of options:

Hyundai Getz: Naaah. Not enough oomph when compared to the Vdi. Average
is pathetic. And the car is more expensive than Vdi + maintenance is on the
higher side. But features a very refined engine. not as peppy as a swift vdi
but refined.

Aveo: Very nice car. Great interiors and built quality. 1.6 engine is a
boon. But outta my budget :(

Fabia: Ooo the debut car of
this year. Spacious but a small 1.2L engine aint powerful as VDi. Price: almost 7L OMG!!!

Problems / Issues:

1. Cabin Noise

2. Plastic quality

3.



Was this review helpful to you ? Yes | No

4 Comment(s) on this Review

  1. on 17 Jul, 2008 at 11:24 PM Sridhar (Chennai)

    Excellent analysis. Really appreciate the home work done here Though I might not agree with all the points 100% (i own a petrol swift :) !!
    I have to post my comments on couple of points which you have mentioned.
    Noise is slightly more then petrol but with the ac on and stereo playing "no difference". - Well, true, however, we are just increasing the noise level above the engine and it might cause issues especially when you are on highway and some lorry wala is honking and you din't look RVM.

  2. on 17 Jul, 2008 at 11:28 PM Sridhar (Chennai)

    And one more point is
    Petrol servicing @ 5000 kms. Diesel servicing @ 10,000kms each = If I remember correctly, this is not true. As per the manual the petrol service is also once in 10,000 KMS.

  3. on 21 Jul, 2008 at 11:45 PM S P Sodhi

    i own a swift LDi and am quiteproud i made a right choice after analysing all cars within approx rs5 lakhs.everything is alright with the swift but the "cabin noise" is irritating.
    the mileage suddenly dropped from 18 kmpl in the begining to 15kmpl now {10000+kms}.(city mileage)
    (highway mileage-24kmpl)

  4. on 27 Aug, 2008 at 01:21 AM Sneh Chanda (Noida)

    Congratulations on your first car...

    your lucky mate, its been more than 2 months i have been waiting for my car from Rohan motors....

Write Your Comment

Please Note: Please be nice, don't be personal in any given cirumstances. If you don't like the review or you think that the information provided is inappropriate, use Report Abuse link just below the review, CarWale.com administrators will take care of it. Any personal attack, harsh comment, abuse or any other kind of offensive comment will be deleted immediately.


Maximum Characters : 4000

Enter the code shown above (If you can't read it: )
Your Email


What's Next
Write your own review Research Swift at CarWale.com
Sell your Swift at CarWale.com Read forum discussions for Swift
Buy used Swift Read blog posts for Swift