You are here : Research » User Written Reviews » Tata Indigo CS LS TDI » Tata Indigo CS LS TDI Reviews

True Value for Money- Indigo CS LS TDI & Dicor

A Review by Bhandarkar on Tata Indigo CS LS TDI
17 June, 2008


Average User Rating :
Model Rating  :   41 reviews
Version Rating:   11 reviews
Write a review
User's Ratings for the car

Style
Comfort
Performance
Value for Money
Fuel Economy
 
Overall
Pros : Legspace , power in Dicor, Improved Suspension,Fuel Efficiency.
Cons : Outdated Bonnet Style, Bad Plastics, No Cent/Lock & Power windows.
Review Popularity

Total Views 3083
People Liked 12
People Disliked 1

The world’s cheapest saloon, the Indigo CS, gets Tata’s common-rail diesel engine (Dicor), and a lot of tweaks to improve the overall package. The CS DiCOR does cost Rs 50,000 more than the existing Indigo CS TDi’s Rs 4.41 lakh, but it is still cheaper than its nearest saloon rival (the Swift Dzire LDi) by a substantial Rs 60,000.


Almost everything about this diesel motor is the same as on the Indica/Indigo DiCOR. It uses the same variable geometry turbocharger, the same 1600-bar common-rail direct injection system, the same twin overhead camshafts and also injects fuel into the cylinders thrice during each combustion cycle. It even uses the same gearbox and, importantly, the shorter gear ratios of the Indica DiCOR. However, there are a few key changes to this engine (from the Indigo DiCOR’s) that improve refinement levels. The engine head covers have been modified and the valves have been optimised to reduce noise. There’s also more material in the firewall (the bit that separates the engine bay from the cabin) to block excess noise from getting to your ears.


The CS feels different from its bigger brother. The tendency to stall is still there, as the engine falls below 1000rpm quite easily. However, once past this, throttle response is perky, and as long as you stay above 1400rpm, part-throttle response is peppy as well. The regular Indigo DiCOR has a lot more lag, something that seems to have been sorted on the CS, thanks to the shorter gears. Flat-out performance is adequate, the CS DiCOR getting to 100kph in 14.9 seconds, but it feels a lot faster than this thanks to the minimal lag in throttle response.


Out on an open road, the CS DiCOR will run to a true 166kph before the engine runs out of breath. And thanks to the short gearing, the engine spins at 2400rpm at 100kph, bang in the middle of its powerband. This means that in most cases, all you need to do to overtake is tap the throttle. We are really thrilled with the improved driveability, because it reduces the need for a gearshift when you need to up the pace. However, the imprecise and rubbery gearshift has been carried over from the regular Indigo; it’s a serious shortcoming in every Indica-based model.


However, the car is certainly more silent. The tweaks to the engine have resulted in a slight improvement over the regular Indigo DiCOR. Yet, you can still hear that familiar gravelly note that is characteristic of the DiCOR motor. It is still lags way behind the Swift Dzire or a Mahindra Logan diesel in terms of refinement.


What we do appreciate is the CS’ improved ride. Tata engineers have played around with the spring rates (made them stiffer) and changed the viscosity of the oil in the dampers and this has made a world of difference. The biggest is the refined feel of the suspension. Handling too has improved, thanks to the suspension tweaks. Body roll is well controlled around corners, and minor adjustments to the steering have improved the on-centre feel, thereby taking the uncertainty out of where the car is heading in a corner. Bottom line, is it worth forking over money for? It meets the needs of interior space, has a boot, a peppy engine and overall fuel efficiency is good as well (15.05kpl). However, its equipment list is short, with only power steering and airconditioning as standard. It doesn’t have power windows, central locking or a rear defogger. The CS DiCOR is available only in this LS trim Model


Still rough around the edges, the Indigo CS DiCOR doesn’t quite hit the spot in terms of general quality and finesse. However, if you want a big car but are on a tight budget, this car delivers all the must-haves.




Was this review helpful to you ? Yes | No

17 Comment(s) on this Review

  1. on 17 Jun, 2008 at 11:06 AM Rajesh (Pune)

    This review seems to be from Autocar India June 08 issue

  2. on 17 Jun, 2008 at 11:32 AM Bhandarkar

    Its a collection of reviews really..
    I have driven the LS TDI, Petrol & Dicor version & couldnt agree with the words more..
    I ma Waiting Eagerly for the Fiat MJ Diesel with ABS from Tata , That would Get a 5 star for sure.. Hopefully the readers will benefit from the review for the present.. but wait for the 1.3LMJ its the ultimate..
    I am from the Auto Industry Myslef so i can tell you that it is the next generation of Engines to come..

  3. on 17 Jun, 2008 at 12:26 PM Bm Patnaik (Nagpur)

    Nice to see Mr.Bhandarkar u started ur own blog. Congrats. Its good to get as much information as possible. What do other magazines have to say in their test reports about the Indigo CS LS TDi?

  4. on 17 Jun, 2008 at 12:35 PM Bhandarkar

    Hello Mr Patnaik,
    wanted to post this review on your comment list for answers on the dicor but there was a space constraint , so had to create a new one..
    but one has to come to ur blog for the best owner review for sure ! hope it helps the Indigo CS admirers.. what say? Hopefull i will write Mine soon with the MJ engine , waiting to own one.
    It would be great if you post some pics of ur aurangabad trip though..

  5. on 17 Jun, 2008 at 05:08 PM Dr Sunil Vasant (Mumbai)

    thanx mr Bhandarkar for the valuable input... such rare things are a treat to go through, congrats! well deserved! and what's this fiat1.3L MJ diesel with ABS you are talking about? i wd appreciate if you can kindly elaborate, am interested to buy a new diesel car and am thinking on swift and CS,LS Dicor lines,so can you kindly suggest which one to go for, or shall i wait for that fiat1.3.... you wrote about... am planning to buy shortly so your view on this will be highly appreciated
    regards,

  6. on 17 Jun, 2008 at 07:53 PM Bhandarkar

    Mr/Miss anonymous?? are u serious??
    thanx for the appreciation but..
    you havent mentioned ur usage or your priority or the budget..
    If ur a self driver, seeking great handling with mileage with no boot space or back seat leg room swift diesel is ur choice..
    It already has the fiat 1.3 engine in it.
    The Fiat grande punto will come in 2 diesel variants of 75 & 90 Bhp with superior handling & ABS options and the reliable build quality + superb design. but ull have to wait will Sep.
    Cost Rs.6

  7. on 17 Jun, 2008 at 08:01 PM Bhandarkar

    but if you want a sedan which has good value for money in terms of performance ease of ownership & maintenance and will not get outdated in the next 3 years it has to be the indigo Cs 1.4l Dicor or hope the tata's deal with fiat for the 1.3L engine breaks through quickly to bring the indigo cs with the next generation multi jet diesel engine. If you can wait i would recommend the Indigo CS Dicor or the swift VDI with ABS.

  8. on 17 Jun, 2008 at 08:28 PM Bhandarkar

    Mr.Rajesh Deshpande has bought a indigo LS TDI for 5.62 onroad recently you can ask the details as the wasnt much useful to him.. hes just driven till the first service..

  9. on 02 Jul, 2008 at 07:42 PM Tushar Phule (Bangalore)

    Good detailing

  10. on 16 Jul, 2008 at 12:40 PM Santosh Kumar (Bangalore)

    Hi, Bhandarkar thanks for the details put by you

    wat is the major diff b/w LD dicor and LS TDI that cost diff 50K around. i am planning to bye sedan type in oct-nov which cost around 5 lc ,please suggest which to go for

  11. on 17 Jul, 2008 at 04:53 PM Bhandarkar

    In short, Resale value, Fuel efficiency & power.
    5 Lac doesnt gie you much option. Its either Indigo CS or the new Hyundai Accent petrol..
    There are a lot of other dual energy cars coming up.. but u will hae to wait for them

  12. on 29 Jul, 2008 at 12:45 PM Prashant Kabra (Hyderabad)

    I finally bought a Indigo CS dicor, the car is superb except for the cheap plastics and the interiors. Mileage looks decent around 15 (with AC most of the time) and around 20-21 on highways. I am proud to have bought this car.

  13. on 29 Jul, 2008 at 02:30 PM Bhandarkar

    Congratulatios.Time for you to write a detailed performance review.. hope u mention how much it cost you on road & how you personalized it to your requirements with the accessories & its cost. It will help others..

  14. on 01 Aug, 2008 at 03:12 PM Prashant Kabra (Hyderabad)

    Thanks. Mr. Bhandarkar. Will do it shortly. Was planning to pen down the complete details.

  15. on 03 Aug, 2008 at 10:04 PM Arvind_K

    Arvind:
    I own a Indica Dicor, 1.4l. I just had done 3000Kms.Amazing fuel efficiency & performance. Its an excellent highway car. I also have a swift Vdi with me and i feel Dicor matches the performance of Swift. I just happened to fit a 'Dragon Digital Tuning Box' for my dicor, and the car now Vrooms... Zooms... ahead of most other crdi's. Hope to get around 85bhp after installing the box. Arvind_k80@yahoo.com

  16. on 03 Aug, 2008 at 10:11 PM Arvind_K

    Good analysis Bhandarkar... I am getting a FE of around 24.9Kmpl with out AC in highways and 23.1 Kmpl with AC. May be i think that reduced weight in Indica is added advantage in Fuel Eff. Moreover after fitting the Digital Tuning Box, i am able to shift to higher gears earlier than before.

  17. on 05 Sep, 2008 at 10:05 PM H K

    Congrats for owning a CS.
    Require help in selecting a car for me with foll reqmt:
    Accomodating family of six (may entail modifying front seat to occupy 3)..dont know whether advisable to do so..I estimate to drive 800-1000 km/mth in city & 200 km on highway..Budget 5-6 lacs..fuel efficiency,comfort,bootspace are important..ABS-not sure..I'm currently confused between Logan v/sIndigo CS v/sIndica Vista MJ..Which one to go for (petrol/diesel)and which model(e.g.logan's available in Edge/GLX/GLS

Write Your Comment

Please Note: Please be nice, don't be personal in any given cirumstances. If you don't like the review or you think that the information provided is inappropriate, use Report Abuse link just below the review, CarWale.com administrators will take care of it. Any personal attack, harsh comment, abuse or any other kind of offensive comment will be deleted immediately.


Maximum Characters : 4000

Enter the code shown above (If you can't read it: )
Your Email


What's Next
Write your own review Research Indigo CS at CarWale.com
Sell your Indigo CS at CarWale.com Read forum discussions for Indigo CS
Buy used Indigo CS Read blog posts for Indigo CS