You are here : Research » User Written Reviews » Mahindra Scorpio W Vlx » Mahindra Scorpio W Vlx Reviews

Good Machine but not real good Value for Money

A Review by Vinay Bhat on Mahindra Scorpio W Vlx
05 June, 2008 (Last Updated: 11 June, 2008)


Average User Rating :
Model Rating  :   40 reviews
Version Rating:   7 reviews
Write a review
User's Ratings for the car

Style
Comfort
Performance
Value for Money
Fuel Economy
 
Overall
Pros : Great Power, Light Steering for City Traffic, Upright Seats,
Cons : Very Bad Leg Space - very less space, Still unstable at high Speeds, Overall Fit Finish not good
Review Popularity

Total Views 2811
People Liked 64
People Disliked 1

I was looking for a MUV/SUV and test drove Scorpio Vlx, and the Innova.  I had always dreamt of owning a scorpio from the time it was launched but could not afford it at that time.  When we test drove the Innova we were pleased with the interiors and the space inside the vehicle and the overall refinement.  But like I said earlier, I always wanted to buy the Scorpio and hence headed towards the nearest Mahindra showroom.  My heart changed once I saw the new Scorpio. 


Exteriors:  The looks of the Scorpio still stings in one's mind. Its tall stance makes you feel like a king of the road.  The headlamps cluster and the tail lamp cluster look well carved out.  However the stickering in the Vlx version makes it look like a chessboard (the only difference between the looks of Crde and Mhawk apart from badging). The looks are however subjective to individuals and hence my personal rating on a scale of 5 would be 4 .


Interiors:  Overall you would not be happy with the interiors of this SUV.  The fit and finish is just not there.  The finish in the center and gearlever and other switches look cheap.  There are storage spaces all over but still you cannot store a book etc.,   The front door map pocket cannot be used until you open the door.  The fabric on the seats is still not of great quality considering you are spending close to Rs.12 Lakhs.  I had hoped that Mahindra would give leather seats and a better finish.  The Steering mounted controls are good and tilt steering is very difficult to operat.  Overall Rating 3.


Performance : Switch on the engine, you would immediately know the difference in refinement of the new mHawk engine and once you drive it you would forget about the fit and finish.  It is really a bomb to drive. There is no lag in power afterall it is 120 BHP engine  and the engine just screams to be unleashed.  Though the body roll is still evident but the braking has improved thanks to the ABS.  Overall the handling is much better than the old scorpio (crde included) .  The steering feels a little more connected you however still dont get the confidence to test the corners at high speeds. I had hoped that Mahindra could work on the body roll of the car. The suspension is improved and the ride is more comfortable now.  I found that the gearshit was a bit hard and it really needed some effort for changing.  The middle row had some space now (on a 7 seater) as it was placed right back, though not as comfortable as a Tata Safari. 


Other : The milage or economy is claimed to be 12 Kmpl in city (though I doubt it) and there are nuemerous gizmos offered for this variant.  The tyretronics, steering mounted audio controls, cruise controls, intelligent wipers are quite good but there are no Airbags (surprising when you consider the cost you are paying).  The reversing of this large SUV is made simple with the smart parking camera which animates the scene behind the scorpio in the parking mirror and alerts you with a beep when you are close to the object.  These are good features but the Mahindra would have a lower end versions.  Driving this SUV in the city is a delight for its light steering and other traffic would make way and respect you.  The follow me home headlamps are good and Overall you would not be disappointed if you are driving. The last seats are best avoided in case of long journeys.


Overall :  Lot of features including cruise control but sadly Air Bags is missing.  The Scorpio just got a change of heart and improved handling.  If only it had other variants it would have been a real value for money.  BTW - I just bought a VLX and just love driving it in the city.  It actually makes you feel like a king though your mind would say it it a touch expensive.


 




Was this review helpful to you ? Yes | No

8 Comment(s) on this Review

  1. on 16 Jun, 2008 at 03:47 PM Vinay Bhat

    Hi It has been close to a month since I am driving around in the new scorpio and am pleased with the respect we get from other vehicles. The milage is only around 10 kmpl in city with the AC on which is not bad. The gears are still hard and requires some effort for changing. The fit and finish and other quality issues still on but it is really comfortable in the City. Have fun driving.

  2. on 11 Sep, 2008 at 03:55 PM S.Prem Kumar

    Thanks Vinay,
    I too test drove the VLX and found the same + and -.I feel that it would have been great if they had added Airbags and an EBD also to aid and enhance traction.
    PREM KUMAR

  3. on 11 Sep, 2008 at 10:35 PM Vinay Bhat

    Thanks Prem, Good to find that someone agrees with my view points. Though the finer issues should have been thought of by Mahindra, I still feel that sometimes the heart rules the head and people still opt for the Scorpio

  4. on 15 Oct, 2008 at 05:09 PM Vinay Bhat

    I am very happy with the Scorpio though the Gears are still stiff, the fit and the finish is still not so good. There are rattling noises and economy is around 10 kmpl in the city. Still I get people saying that it is not a real value for money considering the space and the comforts

  5. on 15 Oct, 2008 at 05:10 PM Vinay Bhat

    If the scorpio was priced a little lower then there would be more buyers.

  6. on 10 Nov, 2008 at 12:34 PM Chandrakant (Mysore)

    Dr chandrakant
    thinking of buying a scorpio am still in dilema looking into its fuel economy,can just someone help me regarding this

  7. on 12 Nov, 2008 at 04:54 PM Srikanth Srinivasan (Bangalore)

    hi chandrakant,
    if u spend a bit more in the initial investment n buy the scorpio, which gives a good 12-14 kmpl at least the vlx version does, and since it runs on diesel..you save up much more in the long run since price difference between diesel and petrol is nearly 20 rs on a per liter basis and other petrol cars also give the same mileage...Ive just purchased the scorpio recently n find it very comfortable especially for long drives. Driving it in the city makes u feel like u own the road

  8. on 13 Nov, 2008 at 03:38 PM Vinay Bhat

    Hi My Scorpio gives around 10 to 11 in the City. I agree that in long drives it is comfortable but the body roll is pretty evident thought not as bad as before. I am generally happy with the Scorpio though I still wish the fit and finish were a little better.

Write Your Comment

Please Note: Please be nice, don't be personal in any given cirumstances. If you don't like the review or you think that the information provided is inappropriate, use Report Abuse link just below the review, CarWale.com administrators will take care of it. Any personal attack, harsh comment, abuse or any other kind of offensive comment will be deleted immediately.


Maximum Characters : 4000

Enter the code shown above (If you can't read it: )
Your Email


What's Next
Write your own review Research Scorpio W at CarWale.com
Sell your Scorpio W at CarWale.com Read forum discussions for Scorpio W
Buy used Scorpio W Read blog posts for Scorpio W